Back to the workspace

Appeal packet

Aetna · Commercial (ERISA self-funded)

Case case_01JQXR7K2MDEMOAETNAMRI · prepared 2026-07-26 · corpus 2026-07-26

Service
72148 · Dx M54.16
Denial type
medical necessity · CARC 50
Route
Internal appeal — level 1 · 29 CFR §2560.503-1(h)(3); 45 CFR §147.136(b)(2)
Filing deadline
January 4, 2027 (162 days remaining)
Strength
STRONG 0.94 — 7 of 8 required criteria met
Governing policy
Aetna CPB 0743 v2026-03-11 · https://www.aetna.com/cpb/medical/data/700_799/0743.html
Packet hash
sha256:9a3fa9c348ebbe2dec9a25eb6a71138a160dbd5c1078d71247c0e908f1b3caf7

Appeal letter

[DATE]

Aetna Appeals and Grievances Department [PAYER APPEALS ADDRESS — see the appeal-rights section of your denial notice]

Re: Appeal of Adverse Benefit Determination

Member name[MEMBER NAME]
Member ID[MEMBER ID]
Group number[GROUP NUMBER]
Claim / reference number[CLAIM NUMBER]
Date of denial noticeJuly 2, 2026
Service at issue72148
DiagnosisM54.16
Appeal levelInternal Level 1
The bracketed fields above are placeholders. OVERTURN never received these identifiers — they were removed in your browser before anything was transmitted. Fill them in on your own machine before sending.

Statement of appeal

This is a request for a level 1 internal appeal of the adverse benefit determination identified above, submitted under 29 CFR §2560.503-1(h)(3); 45 CFR §147.136(b)(2) [1]. Please treat this correspondence as a formal appeal and provide a written determination within the timeframe that authority prescribes.

The determination under appeal

The plan denied the requested service and identified the basis for that decision as follows.

  1. Claim adjustment reason code 50 — These are non-covered services because this is not deemed a 'medical necessity' by the payer.
  2. Remittance advice remark code — N115

The notice states, in the plan's own words:

Conservative management documentation insufficient. The clinical information submitted does not establish that the criteria in the applicable Clinical Policy Bulletin have been met.

This appeal addresses that stated basis directly, criterion by criterion, against the plan's own published coverage policy.

The governing coverage criteria

The determination applied Aetna CPB 0743 — Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) of the Spine, version 2026-03-11 [2].

That policy sets out 8 required criteria. Each is addressed below.

Source: https://www.aetna.com/cpb/medical/data/700_799/0743.html Retrieved 2026-07-20 · content hash `sha256:41f4cccd1c777cf9…`

Criterion-by-criterion demonstration

§II.A.2 — At least six (6) weeks of conservative therapy, including physical therapy, has been completed and documented. [2] This criterion is satisfied in the enclosed record: the PT Discharge Summary (page 1) records: "Patient completed 8 weeks of supervised physical therapy (2x/week, 16 sessions) from 2026-04-14 through 2026-06-09." [3].

§II.A.3 — Symptoms persist or have progressed despite completion of the documented conservative management. [4] This criterion is satisfied in the enclosed record: the PT Discharge Summary (page 2) records: "Symptoms persist despite completion of conservative management, and the patient reports progressive limitation of standing tolerance from 30 minutes at intake to 10 minutes at discharge." [5].

§II.A.4 — The results of the requested imaging study are expected to change clinical management. [6] This criterion is satisfied in the enclosed record: the Office Visit — 2026-06-18 (page 2) records: "The results of the imaging study are expected to change clinical management by determining whether surgical referral is indicated or whether continued non-operative care is appropriate." [7].

§II.A.6 — Plain radiographs of the lumbar spine have been obtained and reviewed prior to advanced imaging. [8] This criterion is satisfied in the enclosed record: the Office Visit — 2026-06-18 (page 1) records: "Plain radiographs of the lumbar spine obtained 2026-05-02 were reviewed prior to consideration of advanced imaging." [9].

§II.A.7 — The member has no implanted device or retained foreign body that contraindicates magnetic resonance imaging. [10] This criterion is satisfied in the enclosed record: the Office Visit — 2026-06-18 (page 2) records: "No implanted device, retained foreign body, or other contraindication to magnetic resonance imaging is present." [11].

§II.A.8 — The requested study is of the anatomic region corresponding to the documented clinical findings. [12] This criterion is satisfied in the enclosed record: the Office Visit — 2026-06-18 (page 2) records: "The study requested is of the lumbar anatomic region corresponding to the clinical findings described above." [13].

§II.A.9 — The study is requested without contrast, unless infection, neoplasm, or prior lumbar surgery is suspected and documented. [14] This criterion is satisfied in the enclosed record: the Office Visit — 2026-06-18 (page 2) records: "MRI lumbar spine is requested without contrast; there is no suspicion of infection, neoplasm, or prior lumbar surgery." [15].

Documentation being supplemented

One criterion is not documented in the enclosed record. This appeal does not assert that it has been satisfied; the supporting documentation is identified below and is being obtained.

§II.A.5 — Neurologic deficit is documented on physical examination. [16] The enclosed record does not document this criterion. An addendum is being obtained to supply it, and will be submitted supplementally.

Requested action

The plan is asked to overturn the adverse determination and authorize the requested service. In the alternative, the plan is asked to identify, by clause number, which specific criterion it maintains is unmet and what documentation it requires to establish it.

One criterion is addressed by documentation that is being obtained and will be submitted supplementally. The plan is asked to hold the file open for that submission rather than issuing a determination on the current record alone.

Appeal rights and timeframes

This appeal is submitted within the applicable filing window of 180 calendar days [1]. The window is calculated as 180 days from receipt of the adverse benefit determination (2026-07-08), which places the filing deadline at January 4, 2027.

A written determination is requested within 15 days.

If this appeal is not resolved in the member's favour, the next available review is external review iro, which must be requested within 120 days under 45 CFR §147.136(d).

Under 29 CFR §2560.503-1(h)(2)(iii), the plan is asked to provide, free of charge, copies of all documents, records, and other information relevant to this claim, including the specific internal rule, guideline, protocol, or other similar criterion relied upon.

Enclosures

  1. Adverse Benefit Determination — 1 page
  2. PT Discharge Summary — 2 pages
  3. Office Visit — 2026-06-18 — 2 pages

To follow:

  1. Addendum addressing §II.A.5

Respectfully submitted,

[SIGNATURE] [NAME] [RELATIONSHIP TO MEMBER / PRACTICE NAME] [CONTACT INFORMATION]

Appendix A — criteria matrix

C1 · §II.A.2 — Met (required)

At least six (6) weeks of conservative therapy, including physical therapy, has been completed and documented.

A passage in the record states the fact this criterion requires; the quote below is copied verbatim from that passage.

C2 · §II.A.3 — Met (required)

Symptoms persist or have progressed despite completion of the documented conservative management.

A passage in the record states the fact this criterion requires; the quote below is copied verbatim from that passage.

C3 · §II.A.4 — Met (required)

The results of the requested imaging study are expected to change clinical management.

A passage in the record states the fact this criterion requires; the quote below is copied verbatim from that passage.

C4 · §II.A.5 — Not documented (required)

Neurologic deficit is documented on physical examination.

The record contains no passage addressing this criterion. Silence is not a contradiction — this is a documentation gap rather than a coverage failure.

Remediation: Request a records addendum from the treating provider documenting the finding required by §II.A.5: "Neurologic deficit is documented on physical examination.". Ask that it name the encounter date and the specific finding, not a general statement.

C5 · §II.A.6 — Met (required)

Plain radiographs of the lumbar spine have been obtained and reviewed prior to advanced imaging.

A passage in the record states the fact this criterion requires; the quote below is copied verbatim from that passage.

C6 · §II.A.7 — Met (required)

The member has no implanted device or retained foreign body that contraindicates magnetic resonance imaging.

A passage in the record states the fact this criterion requires; the quote below is copied verbatim from that passage.

C7 · §II.A.8 — Met (required)

The requested study is of the anatomic region corresponding to the documented clinical findings.

A passage in the record states the fact this criterion requires; the quote below is copied verbatim from that passage.

C8 · §II.A.9 — Met (required)

The study is requested without contrast, unless infection, neoplasm, or prior lumbar surgery is suspected and documented.

A passage in the record states the fact this criterion requires; the quote below is copied verbatim from that passage.

C9 · §III.A.1 — Not applicable (exclusion)

Repeat magnetic resonance imaging of the same anatomic region within twelve (12) months is considered not medically necessary in the absence of a documented change in clinical status, new neurologic findings, or planned surgical intervention.

The record does not document circumstances that would trigger this exclusion, so the exclusion does not apply to this request.

Appendix B — evidence table

CriterionSourceQuoteSHA-256
C1PT Discharge Summary p1“Patient completed 8 weeks of supervised physical therapy (2x/week, 16 sessions) from 2026-04-14 through 2026-06-09.”31d08f8c82a17551f001…
C2PT Discharge Summary p2“Symptoms persist despite completion of conservative management, and the patient reports progressive limitation of standing tolerance from 30 minutes at intake to 10 minutes at discharge.”260ab9ad7a4de11c45d7…
C3Office Visit — 2026-06-18 p2“The results of the imaging study are expected to change clinical management by determining whether surgical referral is indicated or whether continued non-operative care is appropriate.”933c27c111bcd8f9b127…
C5Office Visit — 2026-06-18 p1“Plain radiographs of the lumbar spine obtained 2026-05-02 were reviewed prior to consideration of advanced imaging.”51d122e0b9eaa6d1f2b3…
C6Office Visit — 2026-06-18 p2“No implanted device, retained foreign body, or other contraindication to magnetic resonance imaging is present.”86904a4f5c2d436cf023…
C7Office Visit — 2026-06-18 p2“The study requested is of the lumbar anatomic region corresponding to the clinical findings described above.”9963c2351a7fe257908b…
C8Office Visit — 2026-06-18 p2“MRI lumbar spine is requested without contrast; there is no suspicion of infection, neoplasm, or prior lumbar surgery.”e71a3a4cdb70450ffe14…

Disclaimers

OVERTURN produces a drafted appeal for human review. It is not medical advice, not legal advice, and does not submit anything to any payer — you review, you sign, you send.

Deadlines and appeal routes are computed from published federal and state rules and are shown with their authority citations. Verify them against the appeal-rights section of your own denial notice, which is authoritative.

Criteria matching reflects Aetna CPB 0743 version 2026-03-11, retrieved 2026-07-20, and the documents you provided.